Poll: What Do You Think The Metacritic Score Will Be For...
Related Video

Poll: What Do You Think The Metacritic Score Will Be For GTA 6?

Few video game releases have generated as much anticipation as Grand Theft Auto 6, and Pure Xbox is asking the question on many people's minds: what Metacritic score will Rockstar's next blockbuster land? Whether you think it will be a flawless masterpiece or a slightly bumpy return to Vice City, we want to hear your prediction. Come and give us your verdict.



Why the Metacritic Score Matters So Much



Metacritic has become one of the most recognisable shorthand measures of a game's critical reception. By collating scores from major publications into a single weighted number, it gives fans a quick snapshot of how the press has responded. For a game as huge as GTA 6, that number will be quoted in headlines, forum threads and social media posts for years.



For publishers, a high Metacritic score is also a badge of prestige. It can influence marketing, sway undecided buyers and even affect how a studio's work is remembered. With Rockstar's track record, expectations for the score are already sky-high.



Of course, a number can never tell the whole story of a game. Still, there is something irresistible about trying to guess it before the reviews arrive, and that is exactly what this poll is for.



Looking Back at Rockstar's Previous Review Scores



Rockstar Games has a remarkable history with critics. Grand Theft Auto V holds a score of 97 on Metacritic for its original PlayStation 3 release, while Grand Theft Auto IV reached an astonishing 98 on both PS3 and Xbox 360. Red Dead Redemption 2 also earned a 97 on consoles.



These numbers set an extremely high bar. Few studios have maintained that level of critical acclaim across so many major releases. It means that anything less than the mid-90s could be seen by some as a disappointment, even though most developers would celebrate such a result.



That pressure is part of what makes this poll so interesting. Rockstar is not just competing with other games this year, it is competing with its own legacy.



The Case for a Near-Perfect Score



The optimists have plenty of reasons to be confident. The trailers have shown off staggering visual fidelity, a richly detailed take on Vice City and the wider state of Leonida, and a dual-protagonist story featuring Lucia and Jason. Rockstar has also had years to refine its ideas, and the studio is famous for its polish and attention to detail.



Reviewers have historically rewarded Rockstar's ambition. The worlds feel alive, the storytelling is cinematic and the sheer scale tends to leave critics in awe. If GTA 6 delivers on even most of what has been teased, a score in the high 90s is certainly within reach.



There is also the matter of timing. After such a long wait, critics will be approaching the game with enormous curiosity, and a generation-defining release could earn the kind of glowing praise that pushes a Metacritic score to the very top.



Reasons Why the Score Might Fall Short



Not everyone believes GTA 6 will match the highs of its predecessors. Reviewers may be more critical of familiar formulas, and the open-world genre has evolved considerably since GTA V launched. Some critics may argue that certain design choices feel dated, even if the technical execution is superb.



Another factor is sheer expectation. When a game is built up for years, even a very good review can feel underwhelming against such hype. A score of 90 would be excellent for almost any other release, but it might spark debate in the context of Rockstar's history.



Technical performance could also play a part. If review copies encounter bugs or frame rate issues, critics may be quick to mention them, which could shave a few points off the final tally.



How Review Bombing and User Scores Differ



It is worth remembering that Metacritic has two separate scores: the Metascore from professional critics and the User Score from the public. The two can differ wildly, especially when a game is controversial or when Players feel strongly about particular decisions.



This poll focuses on the critic Metascore, which is generally more stable. User scores can swing dramatically in the first days after launch, driven by passionate fans and occasional review-bombing campaigns.



Whatever you predict, think carefully about which number you are guessing. The Metascore tends to settle quickly after launch, making it the more reliable benchmark for this kind of prediction game.



What Xbox Fans Are Hoping to See



For the Pure Xbox community, the excitement around GTA 6 comes with a particular focus on how it will run on Xbox hardware. Fans are keen to see strong performance, stable frame rates and good visual quality on Xbox Series X and Series S. Any differences between platforms will be scrutinised closely.



Many readers also hope that Xbox players will get a smooth experience with features such as quick resume, online play and cross-generation improvements. If the game launches in great shape on Xbox, it will only add to the positive mood among reviewers and players.



Pure Xbox will, of course, be covering the game extensively as more details emerge, so keep an eye on the site for news, analysis and performance breakdowns.



Could GTA 6 Become the Highest Rated Game Ever?



The boldest predictions suggest GTA 6 might challenge the very top of Metacritic's all-time rankings. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time still sits at 99, a figure that few games have come close to touching. Matching or beating it would be a monumental achievement.



It is a long shot, but it is not impossible given Rockstar's pedigree and the scale of this project. Even getting into the 97 to 99 range would place the game among the most celebrated titles in history.



Realistically, though, such a perfect reception would require near-universal critical praise with very few dissenting voices. That is a tall order for a game this large and complex, which is why the poll is so tricky to call.



Make Your Prediction and Join the Conversation



Now it is your turn. Think about Rockstar's history, the hype, the trailers and the pressures facing the game, then lock in your prediction in our poll. Will it be a 97 to match GTA V, a 98 to match GTA IV, or something completely different?



Once you have voted, head to the comments and tell us why you made your choice. We are curious to see whether the Pure Xbox community leans optimistic or cautious, and whether anyone is brave enough to predict a perfect score.



When the reviews finally arrive, we will revisit this poll and see how close everyone came. Until then, come and give us your verdict.

If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to Contact Us

← Back to Technology News